To be perfectly honest I like the second one better, upon first glance. The first one has some nice things going for it, but overall the second one has a better sense of continuity and seems more like a website for the kind of business you're doing. Some modifications to the first one might make that one better.
If you're going to be using a lot of unique fonts, I recommend using http://www.fontsquirrel.com/, as you can get any amount of fonts free, no page view limits or anything because they're hosted on your site. Small suggestion, seeing as you're only using two unique fonts.