To be perfectly honest I like the second one better, upon first glance. The first one has some nice things going for it, but overall the second one has a better sense of continuity and seems more like a website for the kind of business you're doing. Some modifications to the first one might make that one better.
If you're going to be using a lot of unique fonts, I recommend using http://www.fontsquirrel.com/, as you can get any amount of fonts free, no page view limits or anything because they're hosted on your site. Small suggestion, seeing as you're only using two unique fonts.
Bookmarks