internet.com

Go to WebDeveloper Home


hm-v6-139x61.gif

Database Journal: The Knowledge Center for Database Professionals

find a web host with:
CGI Access
DB Support
NT Servers
UNIX Servers
Telnet Access

advanced search
jobs

Get FREE Development Info via your Email!

The Webdeveloper channel
FlashKit
GIF.com
HiermenusCentral
webdeveloper Jobs
Java Boutique
JavaScript.com
JavaScript Source
ScriptSearch
StreamingMedia World
WDJ
WDVL
WebDeveloper.com
WebReference.com
XMLFiles.com

internet.com
Internet News
Internet Investing
Internet Technology
Windows Internet Tech.
Linux/Open Source
Web Developer
ECommerce/Marketing
ISP Resources
ASP Resources
Wireless Internet
Downloads
Internet Resources
Internet Lists
International
EarthWeb
Career Resources

Search internet.com
Advertise
Corporate Info
Newsletters
E-mail Offers

internet.commerce
Be a Commerce Partner










 
THE XML FILES
A WebDeveloper.com Feature

Not All SMILs

By Nate Zelnick

Industry Standards Still Evolving

The Synchronized Multimedia Integration Language (SMIL), the latest W3C recommendation, is completely in line with the trend of the consortium for the last few months, in that it builds on the other work of the body in an incremental fashion. In this case it means that SMIL, which is used to create time-based presentations that integrate different media objects into a single document, is based on XML.

Scott Clark has already written a ton of excellent articles about SMIL and how to use it, so I’m actually going to depart a little from form here and look at a political argument that has developed around SMIL.

Even though SMIL has been in the works for about 10 months and has had participation from a wide swath of interested commercial companies, its passage as a standard was not without some controversy. According to several press reports, Microsoft voted against the specification even though it had participated in its creation. Microsoft will not support version 1.0 of SMIL in its NetShow and MediaPlayer products in Windows.

Microsoft’s objections to SMIL, according to Group Product Manager Robert Bennett, is that SMIL’s functionality can be done using other technologies that are already standards—namely Cascading Style Sheets, Dynamic HTML and the Document Object Model’s exposure of page elements as named and scriptable objects.

While this argument is largely true, it's not very persuasive. Just because you can do something in one manner, doesn’t always mean it’s the best way for it to be done by everyone in every situation. This is particularly true in the creation of highly functional and widely accessible Internet documents and is, in many ways, exactly why XML is interesting.

Let me explain. The W3C model is predicated on the idea that there are clear distinctions between functional sections of a document to make it available in the widest possible way. HTML and XML define a document’s structure, CSS (and, to a lesser extent to support backward compatibility, HTML) defines a document’s presentation. The DOM defines a generic way to manipulate documents via a standard interface. By following this approach, developers can be reasonably assured that their work can be consumed by an arbitrary client with arbitrary capabilities on an arbitrary platform. If, of course, browser makers on all of those various platforms actually implement the standards as they’ve promised.

So in some sense, Microsoft is correct in its complaint that much of what SMIL is designed to do can be accomplished using the existing technologies and its complaint is not without some merit. But, the argument falls apart when you look at the reality of what SMIL is and what client software is capable of doing.

SMIL’s primary purpose is to define how media objects are displayed over time. While it is certainly possible to script loops that provide triggers for when to display, hide or move objects in a presentation, this gets incredibly complex very quickly when trying to create really interesting multimedia presentations. And that’s before you begin to take into account the frustrating variations in support by even the latest beta version of IE5 and Navigator.

[ Click here to move to the next part of the article ]

Fast Jump to Anywhere on WebDeveloper.com®:





JupiterOnlineMedia

internet.comearthweb.comDevx.commediabistro.comGraphics.com

Search:

Jupitermedia Corporation has two divisions: Jupiterimages and JupiterOnlineMedia

Jupitermedia Corporate Info


Legal Notices, Licensing, Reprints, & Permissions, Privacy Policy.

Advertise | Newsletters | Tech Jobs | Shopping | E-mail Offers

Solutions
Whitepapers and eBooks
IBM Whitepaper: Innovative Collaboration to Advance Your Business
Internet.com eBook: Real Life Rails
Avaya Article: Call Control XML - Powerful, Standards-Based Call Control
Internet.com eBook: The Pros and Cons of Outsourcing
Go Parallel Article: Scalable Parallelism with Intel(R) Threading Building Blocks
Internet.com eBook: Best Practices for Developing a Web Site
IBM CXO Whitepaper: The 2008 Global CEO Study "The Enterprise of the Future"
Avaya Article: Call Control XML in Action - A CCXML Auto Attendant
Go Parallel Article: James Reinders on the Intel Parallel Studio Beta Program
IBM CXO Whitepaper: Unlocking the DNA of the Adaptable Workforce--The Global Human Capital Study 2008
Adobe Acrobat Connect Pro: Web Conferencing and eLearning Whitepapers
Go Parallel Article: Getting Started with TBB on Windows
HP eBook: Storage Networking , Part 1
MORE WHITEPAPERS, EBOOKS, AND ARTICLES
Webcasts
Go Parallel Video: Intel(R) Threading Building Blocks: A New Method for Threading in C++
HP Video: Is Your Data Center Ready for a Real World Disaster?
Microsoft Partner Portal Video: Microsoft Gold Certified Partners Build Successful Practices
HP On Demand Webcast: Virtualization in Action
Go Parallel Video: Performance and Threading Tools for Game Developers
Rackspace Hosting Center: Customer Videos
Intel vPro Developer Virtual Bootcamp
HP Disaster-Proof Solutions eSeminar
HP On Demand Webcast: Discover the Benefits of Virtualization
MORE WEBCASTS, PODCASTS, AND VIDEOS
Downloads and eKits
Microsoft Download: Silverlight 2 Software Development Kit Beta 2
30-Day Trial: SPAMfighter Exchange Module
Red Gate Download: SQL Toolbelt
Iron Speed Designer Application Generator
Microsoft Download: Silverlight 2 Beta 2 Runtime
MORE DOWNLOADS, EKITS, AND FREE TRIALS
Tutorials and Demos
IBM IT Innovation Article: Green Servers Provide a Competitive Advantage
Microsoft Article: Expression Web 2 for PHP Developers--Simplify Your PHP Applications
Featured Algorithm: Intel Threading Building Blocks - parallel_reduce
MORE TUTORIALS, DEMOS AND STEP-BY-STEP GUIDES

Contact the WebDeveloper.com® staff

Last modified: Friday, 22-Aug-2008 13:46:48 EDT

 

Refresh Daily
Join Editor-in-Chief David Fiedler The Editor With No Time and find truth, justice, and a clue or two.


Browse by Category
[ Site Map ]

ActiveX / VBscript
Animated GIF Archive
Browsers
CGI / Perl
Database Connectivity
E-Commerce
HTML-Advanced: DHTML, CSS
HTML / Site Authoring Tools
Intranet/Groupware
Java
JavaScript
Multimedia: Audio / Video / Streaming Technologies
Opinions
Refresh Daily: Editorial Column
Security
Servers & Server Tools
Site Design / Graphics
Site Management / Marketing / Log File Analysis
VRML / 3D
XML